DeviantTracker Audio
- Part of the audio can be isolated using the slider on the audio player.
- The background audio provides a hint to the location of the person recording.
Feline Bone
- Compare this item with information found in the animal identification chart on DeviantTracker.
Flask
- Note the engraving found somewhere on the flask.
Photograph
- Details in the photograph confirm where it was taken.
Receipt
- The coded message can be solved using the same method as the postcard from Episode 3.
DeviantTracker Audio
- The background audio is loud, rushing water.
- Based on the background audio, it was recorded near Highground Falls.
Feline Bone
- The bone's measurements do not match any measurements listed in the animal identification chart.
Flask
- On the bottom of the flask, there is an engraving that reads "C.W.".
Photograph
- There is a waterfall in the photograph, which must be Highground Falls.
Receipt
- The message says: "AUG 31" / "ENACT PLAN" / "CATACOMBS".
Solution
- Lillian Walker can be eliminated from the suspect list.
- Previously, it was established that Toby had to have been killed sometime between 9:00 PM and 10:15 PM. Based on the trail cam photos, the killer was using Tall Pines Trail as a route back to camp from Echo Cavern, and they were on this route from at least 10:15 PM to 10:45 PM. According to the field interviews, everyone was in camp at 11 PM.
- In her field interview, Lillian claims that she hiked to a scenic spot after dinner to obtain footage during golden hour. She said that according to Rusty, the sun would start going down a little after 9:00 PM. True to its name, golden hour lasts one hour, so starting around 9:00 PM, Lillian would have one hour to obtain her footage.
- The photograph appears to have been taken during golden hour and has a timestamp for 21:48 (9:48 PM) on the night of the murder. There is handwriting on the back that has a reminder to "add footage to segment 3". The handwriting can be matched with other handwritten documents to reveal that Lillian wrote this message. Based on this evidence, Lillian was telling the truth in her field interview. The photograph also shows a waterfall in the shot. Referencing the topographical map reveals that the only waterfall in the area, Highground Falls, is located in the southeast part of the region. It would take more than XX minutes for her to travel to the crime scene from this location.
- This implies that Lillian took the photograph at Highground Falls around the approximate time of the murder, which would put her in a faraway location and absolve her of suspicion. This is a moderate alibi, which can be strengthened with another piece of evidence: the DeviantTracker audio. The audio was recorded on the date of the murder and it features Lillian's voice, which can be confirmed to be her by hearing her same voice in the DeviantTracker video clips.
- Using the slider on the DeviantTracker audio player isolates the background audio. The isolated audio is the sound of a waterfall - Highground Falls. This puts Lillian at Highground Falls at the time of the murder, and combined with the information in the photograph, it confirms that the alibi she provided in the field interview is valid. It also confirms that her location was far enough away from Echo Cavern during the time of Toby's death to rule her out as the killer.
- With this confirmation, Lillian Walker can be eliminated as a suspect.
