Class of '98

Physical Items

Episode 5

Bar Tab Receipt 

This places Nic at the Manifest Destiki bar at 9:42 PM, or at least his credit card was there. 

CD Case

This was found in a box of Charlie's high school memorabilia in his home.

 It was tucked partway into the fanny pack that we also received.

It appears to have been a mix CD to Charlie from his high school sweetheart, Robyn. 

  • Wonder what happened to the actual CD... 

Crayon Drawing

This is a drawing by Maggie, showing her mother and another woman standing over a corpse. 

So my first instinct was correct and the "N" that Sarah was texting in code with was Neeta! The corpse is Charlie. 

  • But why is Maggie smiling? 
  • Did she overhear the two women talking and didn't understand the severity of the topic? 

Fanny Pack

This is a blue fanny pack with 3 zippers - 2 on the front, 1 on the back.

On the fanny pack I received, the front 2 zippers were open in the middle and zipped on either side. 

  • Not sure if this is a clue or not... 

There is nothing inside any of the pockets. 

According to Michelle's letter, this was found in a box of Charlie's high school memorabilia. 

Funeral Pamphlet

This is a pamphlet from Charlie's funeral that Michelle snagged from Sarah. 

We get an updated photo of Charlie and a little more background of his life.

Assuming Sarah wrote the obit, she is asking that people contribute to her daughter's college fund. 

Interview Transcript

Haha. Gavin dosed Charlie with Valium unbeknownst to Charlie... 

  • What a pal... 

Gavin explains that he and a chick went into the janitor closet to "relieve a little stress". Ahem. 

  • This explains the mess Arthur Hughes noted during his clean-up.

I love Michelle's come back to that... 

We gather more information for our timeline. Gavin claims Charlie's car was already gone by the time Gavin left the building. 

Letter from Private Investigator

Michelle has done a second run of interviews for Neeta, Robyn, Nic, and Sarah. 

She tells us how to access her collection of suspect addresses on her website


This is a one-way ticket from Illinois to New York for 2 adults and 1 child.

  • Sarah and her lover (Neeta), and Maggie. 

There is a coded message on the back. This can be plugged into the auto shifter on DeviantTracker. 

Once decoded, the message reads: 

  • "One more week, love. Can't wait!" 

This is the same handwriting that was on the gift bag found in Charlie's car. 

Updated Witness Statements

Nicholas Matsoukas 

Nic acknowledges that his mother lied to Michelle during her recent statement. He explains where he was after the reunion and why he wanted to see Charlie afterward.

Robyn Dupre

Robyn was very snobbish. She was complaining about having to be interviewed again, claiming she doesn't remember exact times or events. 

Neeta Patel 

So, she admits she went to Sarah and Charlie's house before heading to the diner. 

  • To tell Sarah of her successful murder? 

Sarah MacDonagh 

What did Neeta want to drop off? She never mentioned dropping anything off in her statement...